OpenACC continuation in Fortran bug?

Hi,

I have a Fortran 90 code that uses OpenACC.
For some directives, the line is very long so I put it on multiple lines using “&”.

I found a problem when trying to reduce a lot of scalars in one directive.
If I do this:

!$acc parallel loop collapse(2) default(present) &
!$acc reduction(+:h_fluxp,h_fluxm,h_fluxp_pn,h_fluxm_pn, &
!$acc h_fluxp_ps,h_fluxm_ps,eqd1,eqd2,h_ax_dipole,h_area_ps)

then the compiler output says:

   1701, Generating NVIDIA GPU code
       1704, !$acc loop gang, vector(128) collapse(2) ! blockidx%x threadidx%x
             Generating reduction(+:h_area_ps,h_fluxm,h_fluxm_ps,h_fluxm_pn,eqd2)
             Generating implicit reduction(+:h_area_pn)

and some of the resulting values are wrong!

I am using:
nvfortran 22.5-0 64-bit target on x86-64 Linux -tp haswell

UPDATE! (even though first post):

It turns out I was missing h_area_pn in the reduction clause and the compiler was implicitly detecting it. However, by doing this - the compiler messed up all the other reductions (which was a bad “silent” bug as the code ran but gave wrong results!)

If I include h_area_pn in the reduction clause - everything is OK.

So it seems that the implicit detection of a reduction scalar is messing up the explicitly declared ones.

– Ron

Hi Ron,

If you can provide a reproducing example, I can take a look and report the issue.

-Mat

Hi,

I sent you a reproducer.

– Ron

Thanks Ron. Filed as TPR #31994

Looks like a regression starting in 21.11. Works correctly with 21.9.